Creighton Bluejays vs Seton Hall Pirates Prediction, Odds and Picks for Today, 03/12/26

Stop busting brackets and sign up for the Pickswise March Madness Premium Picks now! Our expert picked Florida at HUGE +4000 odds last year and is up +30.7 units over the last 3 NCAA Tournaments! Get futures picks and daily best bets throughout all of March Madness, all for just $50. Click here to join and get 20% off before Selection Sunday!

At first glance, this Big East Tournament matchup appears tilted toward Seton Hall. The Pirates enter with a 20-11 record, while Creighton sits at 15-16, which explains why the authors of the line installing Seton Hall as a short favorite makes the Pirates look appealing. However, the spread itself is where the deception begins. The difference between the teams’ records masks the fact that this matchup is far closer stylistically than it appears. Creighton has spent the season battling stronger competition and has developed a profile that tends to perform better in tournament environments. The Jays are built on disciplined defensive structure, kind of like Hall is.

Seton Hall’s season success has largely come from grinding out wins in the regular season, but that style can become vulnerable in neutral-court tournament settings, where every possession is magnified. Creighton’s offense is comfortable operating in slower, possession-by-possession games, which reduces the impact of Seton Hall’s physical style. Another important factor is expectation. Seton Hall’s 20-win season creates the perception of stability, while Creighton’s sub-.500 record discourages support. That imbalance often creates hidden value when the teams meet on neutral floors. Tournament basketball frequently rewards teams capable of executing clean half-court offense late in games. The problem with Seton Hall in particular is, they can’t do that. If they could, they would have upset St. John’s in their season finale. Instead, they dropped another rock fight which they can easily do here. Bluejays outright.

Creighton vs Seton Hall prediction: Creighton +125 (ML) available at time of publishing. Playable to the number.