Caleb Wilfinger
The best of the best across Major League Baseball will take the field in Atlanta, Georgia on Tuesday as the American League looks to win for the 11th time across the last 12 MLB All-Star Games at Truist Park. With that said, the National League has built a very strong roster this year, so there’s a reason why they are slight favorites in the market for this game. In this piece, I’ll be attacking the MLB player prop market and I’ve found 2 plus-money odds plays that you should consider locking in before the game. Let’s dive into the best MLB All-Star Game player prop bets to make for today, while you can also find out our MLB picks for tonight’s matchup as well as all the big games throughout the season.
Find out our 2025 MLB All-Star Game best bet, featuring a 3-star pick from our expert
Best MLB All-Star Game player prop: Aaron Judge to record a hit (+110)
Odds available at DraftKings Sportsbook at time of publishing. Playable to +100.
There aren’t many weaknesses in Aaron Judge’s game, but he has been particularly excellent against right-handed pitching this season. In fact, the AL MVP favorite currently holds a .360 batting average and has slugged 24 home runs against righties in 2025. While Pirates ace Paul Skenes isn’t your average right-hander, Judge will likely get 2 plate appearances in this game, meaning there’s a decent chance he faces a different pitcher in his 2nd plate appearance.
Atlanta is a friendly ballpark for hitters who are able to generate power to left field, and that’s exactly what I expect Judge to do. With large swaths of open grass in left-center and right-center, look for the Yankees’ star outfielder to record his 11th hit in his last 10 games and cash this prop for us. If Judge gets 2 at-bats like most are projecting, I like his chances of recording a hit on Tuesday.
Don’t miss our expert’s 2025 MLB All-Star Game Same Game Parlay picks at +750 odds!
Best MLB All-Star Game player prop: Will Smith to record a hit (+145)
Odds available at DraftKings Sportsbook at time of publishing. Playable to +130.
On the National League side of things, we’re going to travel a bit further down the board and take a shot on Dodgers catcher Will Smith to record a hit. Smith has long established himself as one of the premier catchers in the game, and he’s also in the midst of an excellent 2025 campaign for the league’s best team. What makes Smith so appealing in this game is his ability to hit very well against both right-handed and left-handed pitching.
The veteran backstop holds a .324 batting average with 8 home runs against righties this season, while he’s also hitting .318 with 4 home runs against lefties. Smith’s compact swing that emphasizes a contact-based approach is one that should lend itself well against the elite pitching he’ll face in this contest. Given that he’ll likely get 2 plate appearances, it’s hard not to like Smith’s chances of finding the outfield grass at least once on Tuesday.
Find out our MLB All-Star Game YRFI/NRFI best bet for tonight
