New York Rangers vs Toronto Maple Leafs Prediction, Odds and Picks for Today, 10/16/25

The New York Rangers have already set a record this season. The Rangers became the first team to get shutout in each of their first 3 home games to start the season. The Rangers have yet to score a goal in front of their fans at Madison Square Garden, but the good news is that Thursday’s contest against the Maple Leafs is on the road. New York has scored 10 goals through 2 road games, potting 4 at Buffalo and 6 at Pittsburgh. Toronto has allowed 15 goals through 4 games this season, which is the 5th-most in the league. Despite their home struggles, look for the Rangers to put forth a better offensive output on the road in this one.

While the Maple Leafs have been allowing plenty of goals, they are also scoring plenty of goals. In fact, Toronto’s 17 goals are the most in the league so far this season. The Maple Leaf superstars are off to hot starts, as William Nylander has 7 points already and Auston Matthews has potted a trio of goals. The Rangers haven’t given up many goals thanks to the stellar play of Igor Shesterkin, but going on the road to Toronto is a tough task. Look to the over in this one.

Rangers vs Maple Leafs prediction: Over 6 (-110) available at time of publishing. Playable to -115.