Pickswise
TOR
Toronto Blue Jays21-27, 8-16
4–5
FinalYankee Stadium, New York
NYY
New York Yankees30-19, 16-6
Details1PicksAnalysisParlays

Toronto Blue Jays vs New York Yankees Prediction, Odds and MLB Picks for Tuesday, 05/19/26

🔥 Win Probability

44.8%TOR
Win probability chart
TOR
NYY
55.2%NYY

Probable Pitchers

TOR
TOR
Pitchers
NYY
NYY
Dylan CeaseSP, #84
Dylan Cease
vs
Will Warren
Will WarrenSP, #29
PLAYERW-LERAWHIPIPHKBBHR
D. Cease3-22.981.2257.14584253
W. Warren6-13.611.1852.14962136

Team Stats

TOR
TOR
NYY
NYY
Batting
.265AVG.207
.598OPS.757
0HR2
4RBI5
9H6
4R5
1SB1
3BB6
Pitching
5.63ERA4.00
1.50WHIP1.33
0W1
1L0
12K7
6BB3
2HR0
0SV1
8.0IP9.0
Fielding
1.000FP1.000
0E0
0DP0
7A13
0PO0

Season Series

Current SeriesNYY lead series 2-0
May 18
TOR
TOR6
@
NYY
NYY7
Final
May 19
TOR
TOR4
@
NYY
NYY5
Final
May 20
TOR
TOR-
@
NYY
NYY-
5/20
May 21
TOR
TOR-
@
NYY
NYY-
5/21
Preseason SeriesNYY win series 3-1
Feb 24
NYY
NYY8
@
TOR
TOR7
Final
Feb 28
TOR
TOR1
@
NYY
NYY5
Final
Mar 11
TOR
TOR1
@
NYY
NYY8
Final
Mar 19
NYY
NYY0
@
TOR
TOR11
Final
Regular Season SeriesNYY lead series 2-0
May 18
TOR
TOR6
@
NYY
NYY7
Final
May 19
TOR
TOR4
@
NYY
NYY5
Final
May 20
TOR
TOR-
@
NYY
NYY-
5/20
May 21
TOR
TOR-
@
NYY
NYY-
5/21
Jun 12
NYY
NYY-
@
TOR
TOR-
6/12
Jun 13
NYY
NYY-
@
TOR
TOR-
6/13
Jun 14
NYY
NYY-
@
TOR
TOR-
6/14
Aug 14
NYY
NYY-
@
TOR
TOR-
8/14
Aug 15
NYY
NYY-
@
TOR
TOR-
8/15
Aug 16
NYY
NYY-
@
TOR
TOR-
8/16
Aug 21
TOR
TOR-
@
NYY
NYY-
8/21
Aug 22
TOR
TOR-
@
NYY
NYY-
8/22
Aug 23
TOR
TOR-
@
NYY
NYY-
8/23

Injury Report

NYY
NYY
PlayerPosInjuryReturn
J. Caballero
SSRight FingerMay 20
G. Cole
SPRight ElbowMay 21
G. Stanton
DHRight CalfMay 28
T. MacGregor
SPUndisclosedMay 31
J. Dominguez
LFLeft ShoulderJun 1
TOR
TOR
PlayerPosInjuryReturn
E. Clement
2B IllnessMay 19
F. Perez
PNot Injury RelatedMay 19
N. Lukes
RFLeft HamstringMay 24
Y. Garcia
RPRight ElbowMay 24
C. Stubbs
CUndisclosedMay 25

Standings

2026 American League East Standings

TeamWLGBSTRKPCT
Tampa Bay3215-W3.681
New York30193W2.612
Toronto212711.5L2.438
Boston212711.5W2.438
Baltimore212812L2.429