Indiana Hoosiers

Indiana Hoosiers vs Penn State Nittany Lions Prediction, Odds and Picks for Today, 11/08/25

Beaver StadiumFOX
Indiana
9-0
Indiana
Today
Penn State
3-5
Penn State
Penn State Nittany Lions
Google News

Indiana vs Penn State Pickswise Expert Predictions

Point Spread Pick
Penn State +15.0(-110)

What can we say? Indiana has been boat-racing just about everyone it has seen this year — with the lone exception being Iowa. Many will argue the Hoosiers could be the best team in the country, and it’s hard to push back. They’ve been balanced, explosive, and punishing – a dynamic offense, stingy defense, and an overall physicality that’s overwhelmed opponents. Indiana has been running teams over, make no mistake. Penn State, meanwhile, has been a disappointment in market terms. The Nittany Lions have covered just once all season and are coming off another ATS loss at Ohio State. In that game, PSU hung tough — down only 3 at the half as an 18.5-point dog — before getting blanked 21-0 in the third and never recovering.

So why back Penn State here? Value. In the summer look-ahead line, the Nittany Lions were as high as -16.5 in some spots. Now they’re catching over 2 touchdowns— an over 30 point market flip once you factor preseason expectations vs. current perception. That’s a classic buy-low underdog number, and this time it’s in Happy Valley. If there was ever a “right spot” for Penn State to rise up and turn its season narrative around, this is it. Don’t be shocked if the Nittany Lions don’t just cover, but flirt with the outright upset.

Indiana vs Penn State prediction: Penn State +15 (-110) available at time of publishing. Playable at that number.

Check out Bet365, the world’s #1 sportsbook. They have an amazing sign-up offer where you can INSTANTLY receive $200 in bonus bets from a $5 wager, regardless of whether that bet wins or loses! There’s no catch, it’s really that simple. Join Bet365 right now ⏰ in time to fade or follow our experts’ Indiana vs Penn State predictions.

Napier Montgomery
Game Totals Pick
Under 49.0(-110)

This total ties directly into the side. If Penn State is going to hang around, it will be on the back of its defense. The Nittany Lions simply don’t have the offensive consistency right now to trade punches in a track meet. The backup quarterback situation has been limiting, Nicholas Singleton hasn’t delivered the breakout campaign many expected, and the offensive rhythm just hasn’t materialized. So, how does Penn State keep this one competitive? Slowing it down. Limiting possessions. Leaning on defense, field position, and physicality — the traditional Happy Valley blueprint. The Nittany Lions don’t want a shootout. They can’t win a shootout. They know it, and the game plan reflects it.

Indiana, for its part, has a high-powered attack — but this Penn State defense is still a prideful unit and plays at another level at home. They will not roll over, even against one of the nation’s top offenses. If the Lions are going to cash and potentially shock the system while doing so, this game has to stay tight and gritty — not fast and flashy. Low-scoring script. Defensive resistance. Fewer possessions. Correlated with the home dog. Under 49 is the play, and it matches exactly how Penn State wants this game to unfold.

Indiana vs Penn State prediction: Under 49 (-110) available at number posted. Playable at that number.

Napier Montgomery
Photo of Napier Montgomery

Napier Montgomery

College football handicapper for Pickswise, specializing in college football, soccer and college basketball. Much prefer betting on the smaller/forgotten games than the big matchups, where the lines are a lot more vulnerable. PhD in Victorian Literature, putting my skills of the written word to the test with betting analysis.
Read more about Napier Montgomery

Featured In

Pickswise
*
By signing up you agree to our terms and privacy policy