Caleb Wilfinger
With the Dallas Cowboys and Philadelphia Eagles set for an NFC East showdown on Thursday Night Football kickoff on September 4, the NFL regular season is right around the corner. With the 2025 season rapidly approaching, our team at Pickswise is diving headlong into its coverage for upcoming campaign. Our analysis and projections for the NFL futures market continues with a look at the Comeback Player of the Year Award.
A season ago, this award went to Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow, who bounced back from injury with a tremendous season, despite the fact that his team missed the playoffs. Will another quarterback take down this award once again? The betting market certainly thinks so. Who will be the NFL Comeback Player of the Year in 2025? Let’s take a look at the NFL CPOY odds and my best bet to make.
Want more NFL futures picks? Get our expert’s NFL MVP best bets, including a +4000 longshot
2025 NFL Comeback Player of the Year odds
Odds reflect best numbers available at DraftKings Sportsbook at time of publishing.
Here are the odds:
- Dak Prescott +275
- Aidan Hutchinson +300
- Christian McCaffrey +375
- Trevor Lawrence +475
- J.J. McCarthy +1000
- Nick Chubb +1200
- Daniel Jones +2500
- Maxx Crosby +2500
- Stefon Diggs +2500
Looking for a new sportsbook for the upcoming NFL season? Make sure you check out BetMGM, where right now new users can receive up to $1,500 back in bonus bets if their first bet doesn’t win! Click here to join BetMGM.
NFL Comeback Player of the Year best bet: Aidan Hutchinson (+300)
Odds available at DraftKings Sportsbook at time of publishing.
At first glance, I wanted to back Dak Prescott with a wager in this market. After all, the Cowboys starter is coming back from a hamstring injury and the veteran quarterback finished in the top 5 of MVP voting 2 seasons ago, so it’s certainly possible that he and this Cowboys team overachieves a bit. We know that Dallas is a team that the NFL media and voters could get behind, but I just cant get there with Prescott as the favorite for this award. Instead, I’m going to look toward the Detroit Lions and target their franchise defensive end to have an inspiring bounce-back season en route to claiming this award.
Aidan Hutchinson has had a tremendous start to his career in Detroit, quickly establishing himself as one of the best players in the sport. However, in his 3rd season with the Lions, Hutchinson was sadly forced to miss most of last season after fracturing both bones in his lower leg in Week 6 against the Cowboys. While he’s still a very young player, Hutchinson is the leader of the Detroit defense and the Lions clearly were much worse off without him last fall. Recent reports from training camp have been very encouraging for the defensive lineman, leading me to believe that he should approach this season with vigor and can be expected to bounce back in a big way.
It’ll be an inspiring story if Hutchinson is able to perform at a high level once again following a serious injury, which presents us with a compelling case for taking this number at +300. While Hutchinson is one of the favorites in this market, Burrow was the favorite heading into the 2024 campaign, so the obvious selections do have a tendency to win this award in recent years. Let’s take a shot on Hutchinson to have an excellent comeback season and hope that the voters are also taken with his story.
Check out our Super Bowl 60 predictions, including a +650 best bet
