

The total is a representation of two wildly different situations when each team has the ball. The market knows the Texans, particularly coming off a mind-blowing loss, can dominate Indy’s defense at home. The market also has little hope that the Colts can do much of anything offensively. Just look at last Sunday, when a depleted Colts roster got outgained 293-276 against the 1-8 Dolphins, who deployed a QB making his first-ever NFL start. Yikes.
In most ways, the Colts’ offense is a shell of what it was in recent years. Even under acclaimed offensive mind Shane Steichen, Daniel Jones is in a challenging situation without the trio of wide receivers he expected to have at this point in the season. Jones, who infamously panics when pressured in the pocket, is also sacked at a constant rate. He was untouched in just one game this season but has fallen 25 times behind the line of scrimmage. That’s also led to one of the worst TD-INT ratios in the league (7-12).
The Indianapolis offense still has Jonathan Taylor, one of the league’s most consistent running backs. Even with the Colts’ failures, he remains top-10 in rushing yards (739) and touchdowns (8). The Texans are a formidable run defense, permitting just 102.6 yards per game (11th), but Taylor is always a threat to break open a huge gap.
On the other side, the Texans’ offense is in a completely different situation than Week 3, when they lost to the Colts at Indianapolis. CJ Stroud was without his top receivers in that game – no Nico Collins and no Tank Dell. The Colts were also 0-2, full of hope, at home, and they had yet to trade DeForest Buckner, their best defensive player. Making matters worse for the Colts, both of their starting cornerbacks, Sauce Gardner and Charvarius Ward, were banged up in Week 10 and may legitimately sit out Thursday’s contest.
If the Colts have any hope in this game, it’ll be found in Taylor and a desperate Jones playing for his future. The latter may result in turnovers and more short fields for the Texans, too. Either way, with Houston ready to create separation in a game they need to win and this matchup occurring in a dome, we project a higher-than-average total.
Colts vs Texans prediction: Over 44.5 (-105) available at time of publishing. Playable to 45.5 (-110).
Watching the NFL for as long as we have, it is not surprising to see how the market reacted to this opening Week 11 contest. Classically, on one side, it's the Houston Texans, at home after an embarrassing loss, who are massive favorites. Houston had a tremendous opening half but completely fell apart last week at Cleveland. Markets are still valuing the Texans (3-6), who looked dominant in the first half against the Browns, as a playoff contender; around +185 to make the postseason. Urgency will be at an all-time high as they head back to H-town on a short week.
On the other sideline will be the visiting Indianapolis Colts, a victorious program last week but a relative disaster this season. Already selling Quenton Nelson, DeForest Buckner, Keenan Allen, and Josh Downs before the trade deadline, it’s clear that the Colts are calling it in for the season, at least theoretically. Now players like Jonathan Taylor and Daniel Jones are playing for their individual futures, if nothing else, which is certainly something to consider.
The Colts did well enough last week to defeat the Dolphins, but they’re a consensus bottom-feeder and were forced to play Kyle McCord at QB, who made his first start. Jones wasn’t a huge part of Indy’s success. Clearly missing the crew of wide receivers he had at the start of the season (let alone Alec Pierce, who remains on the injured reserve), Jones was just 11-22 for 108 yards, one touchdown and two interceptions against an underrated Dolphins’ resistance. He will face a considerably tougher test at Houston on Thursday night.
Houston hopes to get Danielle Hunter and Azeez Al-Shaair back on Thursday night, but neither practiced on Monday. Either way, the Texans have a positive matchup against a turnover-prone Daniel Jones. The talented Jonathan Taylor is always a threat, and the Texans haven’t exactly been world beaters against the run this year, either (4 yards per carry allowed, 13th).
It's on defense where we think the Colts will have real problems. CJ Stroud has been legitimately lethal this season (just three INTs, 19 touchdowns, and top seven in QBR and yards) and looks even better with Tank Dell. The Indianapolis Colts’ defense is, in case you haven’t noticed, horrid (bottom six in points and yards allowed). In general, Houston’s offense has been their more consistent unit, top-10 in yards and points. The Colts have allowed 28 points per game over the past six weeks.
Everything is in favor of the Texans here. They get to prepare at home all week, the playoffs remain a reality, they have a far more talented defense, and offensively they should be able to do whatever they want. Houston should also get back David Montgomery for TNF. Even with some inflation, we can only look at the Texans.
Colts vs Texans prediction: Texans -12.5 (-108) available at time of publishing. Playable to 13.5 (-110).
