Pickswise
Best NHL prop bet for today, 5/23 - Jamie Benn breaks through Vegas

Best NHL prop bet for today, 5/23 - Jamie Benn breaks through Vegas

Pickswise_Test
Pickswise_TestAuthor
UpdatedSep 15, 2026
Reading time2 min

The 2023 Western Conference Finals got off to the same start as the Eastern Conference Finals – with a team taking a 2-0 lead. Vegas was able to win each of the first 2 matchups on home ice and both were overtime wins. Now the series shifts to Dallas, where Jason Robertson and the Stars will be looking to get their first win.

The Stars have been a solid home team, so a 2-2 series heading back to Vegas wouldn’t be a shock. However, given how we’ve already seen 2 overtime games, predicting a winner may not be your preferred approach. With that in mind, we have our top NHL player prop for tonight’s Game 3. 

Along with our NHL player prop, be sure to check out all of our NHL picks for the Stanley Cup Playoff action.

You can bet on today’s NHL player props with FanDuel, America’s #1 sportsbook, which has the best odds available and a great sign-up offer where you can get a No Sweat First Bet up to $1,000! Click here to take advantage of this offer and gain access to tons of odds boosts on site.

Jamie Benn over 0.5 points (-140)

When it comes to the Stars, it’s primarily Robertson that gets most of the headlines and he has come through for us countless times over the last 2 seasons. However, today we’re focused on Dallas captain Jamie Benn. After a slow year last season, the 33-year-old had a resurgence in 2022-23. Benn had the 2nd-most points on the team with 78 and has come up clutch several times in the playoffs. 

A perfect example of that was in Game 1 of this series as Benn had the game-tying goal that sent things into overtime. The captain has also provided a great balance of goals and assists, with 33 and 45 respectively this season. In other words, we’re getting great value on his overall point prop. That is amplified even more so with Game 3 being on home ice for him. We can also look back on how Benn performed against Vegas in the regular season, when he had 3 points in 3 games against them. With the Stars needing this win more than ever, I’m backing Jamie Benn to record a point.

Be sure to check out our Vegas Golden Knights vs Dallas Stars predictions and Same Game Parlay

You can bet this player prop over at Caesars Sportsbook, which has an epic sign-up offer where you can get up to $1,250 back on your first bet. Click this link to join Caesars and also benefit from odds boosts every day.

Pickswise is the home of free NHL Picks and NHL Predictions. Check back for our daily NHL Best Bets, including our favorite NHL Prop Bets.

Exclusive Offers
See all
Polymarket — Deposit $10, Get a $50 Trading Bonus
Polymarket
PolymarketDeposit $10, Get a $50 Trading Bonus
$50
Novig — Deposit $10, Get $25 in Trade Credits
Novig
NovigDeposit $10, Get $25 in Trade Credits
$25
Underdog — First-Time Deposit Match + Keep Your $1,000,000
Underdog
UnderdogFirst-Time Deposit Match + Keep Your $1,000,000
$1,000,000
Onyx Odds — Spend $10, Get $111 in Bonus Picks
Onyx Odds
Onyx OddsSpend $10, Get $111 in Bonus Picks
$111
Bet365 — Bet $10, Get $365 in Bonus Bets, Win or Lose
Bet365
Bet365Bet $10, Get $365 in Bonus Bets, Win or Lose
$365
Fanatics — Bet $20, Get $350 in FanCash
Fanatics
FanaticsBet $20, Get $350 in FanCash
$350
BetMGM — Get Up to $1500 in Bonus Bets if your First Bet Does Not Win
BetMGM
BetMGMGet Up to $1500 in Bonus Bets if your First Bet Does Not Win
$1,500
ProphetX — Trade $50, Get $75
ProphetX
ProphetXTrade $50, Get $75
$75
Rebet — Get a 100% Deposit Match up to $100
Rebet
RebetGet a 100% Deposit Match up to $100
$100
FanDuel — Bet $5, Get $350 in Bet Reset Tokens over 7 Days
FanDuel
FanDuelBet $5, Get $350 in Bet Reset Tokens over 7 Days
$350
When you click our links to visit an operator and sign up, we may receive a commission at no extra cost to you. This financial relationship helps support our site.
Pickswise
Get exclusive 
free sports picks
to your email
subscriber 1
subscriber 2
subscriber 3
18K users have
already subscribed
Enter your email address
By signing up you agree to our terms and privacy