Toronto Blue Jays vs New York Yankees Prediction, Odds and Picks for Today, 05/19/26

The New York Yankees will be hosting the Toronto Blue Jays for Game 2 of a four-game series on Tuesday night. The Yankees took Game 1 by a score of 7- after trailing 5-3 late into the ball game. They hit two 2-run homers to take a 7-5 lead and hung on from there. We have a good pitching matchup on our hands in Tuesday’s game between Dylan Cease and Will Warren. Cease has struck out seven or more batters in each of his last three starts and has only given up four earned runs in those starts. Warren for the Yankees has a 3.42 ERA in 47.1 innings pitched on the season. The Jays showed that aside from a few long balls given up late in the game and some defensive mistakes, that they deserved to win Game 1. The Yankees have not been playing well lately as they are only 3-7 in their last 10 games played.

I think the Blue Jays could find their way back to the win column on Tuesday. They have some momentum from a series win in Detroit and they scored six runs on Monday. They have the starting pitching advantage, so there is some good value on them here. Give me the Blue Jays in this one.

Blue Jays vs. Yankees prediction: Blue Jays ML (+115) available at time of publishing. Playable to +100.

Sign up for Polymarket RIGHT NOW to get instant access and a $50 trading bonus after you make your first $20 deposit! You can join Polymarket by clicking here and trade on our Blue Jays vs Yankees predictions.