Pickswise
Best NHL player prop bets for today 5/2: The Matthews keep producing

Best NHL player prop bets for today 5/2: The Matthews keep producing

Ryan Hodges
Ryan HodgesAuthor
UpdatedApr 29, 2026
Reading time4 min

The NHL Playoffs second round kicks off on Tuesday with a couple of teams that a few weeks ago were not expected to be here, but that is part of the beauty of playoff hockey. The Panthers and Maple Leafs have each won high-scoring series, while the Kraken and Stars won the low-scoring series. If those trends hold true, we’re in store for another long and entertaining second round. The high-scoring trends of Florida-Toronto give their player props better value.

If you are looking to have some action yourself, here are our favorite NHL player prop bets for Tuesday’s schedule. You can also check out our NHL picks for each of today’s games.

Today’s NHL props are available at DraftKings Sportsbook, and if you sign up right now, then you can bet $5 and secure $150 in bonus bets IMMEDIATELY! Head over to DraftKings now by clicking this link.

Auston Matthews anytime goalscorer (-125)

The Maple Leafs finally got over the hump of the first round and as expected, Auston Matthews was a major reason why. Matthews led the team with 5 goals in the series as part of his 9 points in 6 games. All 5 goals came in Games 3-6 of the series, so he is riding a 4-game goal streak. As the games became more and more important, Matthews showed up. Now that Toronto is finally in the second round and one step closer, their foot should be fully on the gas. The incentive and chip on the shoulder speaks for itself and it certainly does not hurt that that the physical talent matches the chip on the shoulder, and Matthews has a heck of a supporting case.

He centers the Leafs’ top line, currently between William Nylander and rookie Matthew Knies, who has more than held his own thus far. Matthews is also on the top power-play unit with Mitch Marner, who led Toronto with 11 points against Tampa, plus John Tavares, Ryan O’Reilly and Morgan Reilly. The Maple Leafs’ matchup against the Panthers appears likely to be a high-scoring series. Both teams were top 9 in the NHL in goals scored per game, and the Panthers did not excel in goal prevention. The over was prominent in both teams’ opening series. It would not be surprising to see those trends continue based on the matchup alone. In high-scoring games, it is all but a formality that Matthews will be involved.

Check out our Panthers vs Maple Leafs Same Game Parlay

Bet like a Caesar with this awesome new customer offer from Caesars, where you can get up to $1,250 back on your first bet! Click here to join Caesars, where you can bet on our NHL player prop picks.

Matthew Tkachuk over 0.5 power-play points (+115)

Similar to Matthews, Matthew Tkachuk was also a massive reason why his team won in the first round as he co-led the team with 5 goals. What gives the power-play prop value is that Tkachuk is a massive piece of the Panthers’ power play and the chances that this game could get chippy. Someone could point to any number of factors that drove the Panthers to beat a historically good Bruins team in round 1. But arguably the biggest factor was their toughness. This Panthers team is arguably the biggest bully left in the playoffs. If they can get the Maple Leafs off their game and drag them into a battle of toughness, Toronto could take avoidable penalties.

The Maple Leafs took 8 penalties in game 1 against the Lightning. They were getting beaten, they were frustrated and several players lost their cool. Maybe they will not take 8 penalties again, but it would not be out of the question that Toronto takes some liberties on this Florida team that thrives in that type of chaos. The Panthers have taken the 2nd-most penalties thus far in the playoffs and somehow got away with it. They play the game on the edge and will look to drag their opponents into that style. Tkachuk is fantastic on the power play and his already good chances of tallying a point would be amplified with each power play the Panthers receive.

BetMGM is the king of online sportsbooks, and right now they have a great new customer promotion where you can claim a $1,000 deposit bonus by signing up right now! Click this link to join BetMGM.

Pickswise is the home of free NHL Picks and NHL PredictionsCheck back for our daily NHL Best Betsincluding our favorite NHL Prop Bets.

Exclusive Offers
See all
Polymarket — Deposit $10, Get a $50 Trading Bonus
Polymarket
PolymarketDeposit $10, Get a $50 Trading Bonus
$50
Novig — Deposit $10, Get $25 in Trade Credits
Novig
NovigDeposit $10, Get $25 in Trade Credits
$25
Underdog — First-Time Deposit Match + Keep Your $1,000,000
Underdog
UnderdogFirst-Time Deposit Match + Keep Your $1,000,000
$1,000,000
Onyx Odds — Spend $10, Get $111 in Bonus Picks
Onyx Odds
Onyx OddsSpend $10, Get $111 in Bonus Picks
$111
Bet365 — Bet $10, Get $365 in Bonus Bets, Win or Lose
Bet365
Bet365Bet $10, Get $365 in Bonus Bets, Win or Lose
$365
Fanatics — Bet $20, Get $350 in FanCash
Fanatics
FanaticsBet $20, Get $350 in FanCash
$350
BetMGM — Get Up to $1500 in Bonus Bets if your First Bet Does Not Win
BetMGM
BetMGMGet Up to $1500 in Bonus Bets if your First Bet Does Not Win
$1,500
ProphetX — Trade $50, Get $75
ProphetX
ProphetXTrade $50, Get $75
$75
Rebet — Get a 100% Deposit Match up to $100
Rebet
RebetGet a 100% Deposit Match up to $100
$100
FanDuel — Bet $5, Get $350 in Bet Reset Tokens over 7 Days
FanDuel
FanDuelBet $5, Get $350 in Bet Reset Tokens over 7 Days
$350
When you click our links to visit an operator and sign up, we may receive a commission at no extra cost to you. This financial relationship helps support our site.
Pickswise
Get exclusive 
free sports picks
to your email
subscriber 1
subscriber 2
subscriber 3
18K users have
already subscribed
Enter your email address
By signing up you agree to our terms and privacy