Pickswise
Week 16 same game parlay: Indianapolis Colts vs. Pittsburgh Steelers (+1568)

Week 16 same game parlay: Indianapolis Colts vs. Pittsburgh Steelers (+1568)

Pickswise_Test
Pickswise_TestAuthor
UpdatedApr 29, 2026
Reading time3 min

The two AFC divisions yet to be decided could determine their winners on Sunday as the 11-3 Pittsburgh Steelers host the 10-4 Indianapolis Colts. The Steelers have lost three in a row and haven’t looked good doing it, and they’ll face an even tougher challenge this week as their defense matches up against the relentless Indianapolis offense.

If the Steelers manage to reverse course and win, they’ll finally clinch the AFC North that’s looked out of reach for weeks but has become interesting as the season comes to a close. The Tennessee Titans will win the South if they beat Green Bay and the Colts lose to Pittsburgh. With playoff hosting rights on the line, the only way to make Sunday’s game even more exciting is by playing a same-game parlay. We recommend this four-way play.

Over 47.5 Alternate Total (+170)

James Conner Over 39.5 Rushing Yards (-112)

Jonathan Taylor Anytime Touchdown Scorer (+130)

JuJu Smith-Schuster Under 54.5 Receiving Yards (-112)

FanDuel is offering this parlay at +1568. The great thing about an SGP is that the props are correlated – you can select props that are more likely to happen as a combination, and still receive the odds boost. Let’s break it down one by one.

Over 47.5 Alternate Total (+170)

At the time of writing, the over-under for this game sits at 43. While that number makes sense for any Steelers game, it’s a shockingly low total for the Colts, who have scored at least 26 points in eight of their past nine games. Their defense is error-prone, and while Pittsburgh’s offense is struggling, they showed earlier in the season that they have the capability to move the ball down the field like a playoff team. In such an important game, look for them to do just that. While five points can make all the difference in the world, it’s still less than a touchdown, so bump the total up 4.5 for much better odds.

James Conner Over 39.5 Rushing Yards

Conner missed last week’s game against Cincinnati with a quad injury, and didn’t do anything notable the week before against Buffalo. But he’s been cleared to go for Week 16 and is motivated to put some numbers up on the stat sheet, both for his team’s sake and his own as he heads into free agency. The Colts have a top-five rushing defense, but they still allow almost 100 rushing yards per game, on average. Conner should receive the majority of Pittsburgh’s touches, and even an average game by his standards will hit the over.

Jonathan Taylor Anytime Touchdown Scorer (+130)

Rookie running back Jonathan Taylor is quickly becoming one of the league’s brightest young rushing stars. Taylor ran for 83 yards and a touchdown last week after three consecutive games of 90 or more. He’s scored at least once in three straight games, and he’ll be the obvious choice for Indianapolis when they make their way into the red zone. While Taylor won’t match the six touchdowns that Alvin Kamara scored on Friday, expect him to find the end zone at least once.

JuJu Smith-Schuster Under 54.5 Receiving Yards (-112)

Smith-Schuster made headlines this week when he announced he’ll stop dancing on his opponents’ logos before games following three straight losses. But don’t expect that to change much on Sunday. First of all, it’s a home game for Pittsburgh. Also, whether you do or don’t believe that had any impact on his performance, Ben Roethlisberger certainly doesn’t, and he’s not going to start giving more looks to Smith-Schuster, who has under 100 receiving yards in his last three games combined. After a strong start to the season, he’s broken 40 yards just once in his past five games as Roethlisberger has relied increasingly on other options like Diontae Johnson.

Pickswise is the home of free NFL picks. Check out the latest NFL props and NFL parlays as well as expert underdog predictions and computer picks.

Exclusive Offers
See all
Polymarket — Deposit $10, Get a $50 Trading Bonus
Polymarket
PolymarketDeposit $10, Get a $50 Trading Bonus
$50
Novig — Deposit $10, Get $25 in Trade Credits
Novig
NovigDeposit $10, Get $25 in Trade Credits
$25
Underdog — First-Time Deposit Match + Keep Your $1,000,000
Underdog
UnderdogFirst-Time Deposit Match + Keep Your $1,000,000
$1,000,000
Onyx Odds — Spend $10, Get $111 in Bonus Picks
Onyx Odds
Onyx OddsSpend $10, Get $111 in Bonus Picks
$111
Bet365 — Bet $10, Get $365 in Bonus Bets, Win or Lose
Bet365
Bet365Bet $10, Get $365 in Bonus Bets, Win or Lose
$365
Fanatics — Bet $20, Get $350 in FanCash
Fanatics
FanaticsBet $20, Get $350 in FanCash
$350
BetMGM — Get Up to $1500 in Bonus Bets if your First Bet Does Not Win
BetMGM
BetMGMGet Up to $1500 in Bonus Bets if your First Bet Does Not Win
$1,500
ProphetX — Trade $50, Get $75
ProphetX
ProphetXTrade $50, Get $75
$75
Rebet — Get a 100% Deposit Match up to $100
Rebet
RebetGet a 100% Deposit Match up to $100
$100
FanDuel — Bet $5, Get $350 in Bet Reset Tokens over 7 Days
FanDuel
FanDuelBet $5, Get $350 in Bet Reset Tokens over 7 Days
$350
When you click our links to visit an operator and sign up, we may receive a commission at no extra cost to you. This financial relationship helps support our site.
Pickswise
Get exclusive 
free sports picks
to your email
subscriber 1
subscriber 2
subscriber 3
18K users have
already subscribed
Enter your email address
By signing up you agree to our terms and privacy